For many people with facial paralysis, the most difficult problem — and the one that actually needs the most urgent attention — is often not the asymmetry of the smile but the inability to close the eye fully. Known medically as lagophthalmos, this condition is far more than a cosmetic flaw: left untreated, it is a serious eye health problem that can lead to permanent loss of vision.

In this article you will find a detailed explanation of why the eye does not close in facial paralysis, when surgery is needed, the surgical methods used (gold weight implant, tarsorrhaphy, lower eyelid surgery, dynamic reanimation), recovery after surgery and answers to the most common questions.

Why Doesn’t the Eye Close in Facial Paralysis?

The muscle that closes the eyelids is the orbicularis oculi (musculus orbicularis oculi). The nerve that drives this muscle is the facial nerve, the 7th cranial nerve. Facial paralysis means that this nerve has lost its function.

When the facial nerve is paralysed:

  • The muscle that closes the upper eyelid is paralysed, but the muscle that opens it (levator palpebrae superioris) remains intact because it is driven by the 3rd cranial nerve.
  • As a result, the force pulling the upper lid up persists while the force bringing it down disappears.
  • The eyelid either does not close at all, or a white gap remains when the patient tries to close it.

Muscle tone is also lost in the lower lid, so it turns outward (paralytic ectropion) and sags. This also disrupts the natural drainage of tears. In addition, the midface sags and descends earlier, pulling the lower eyelid down even further.

Most Common Causes

Cause Explanation
Bell’s palsy The most common cause. Usually viral; in most cases it resolves spontaneously within 3–6 months.
Ramsay Hunt syndrome Caused by the herpes zoster virus; the recovery rate is lower than in Bell’s palsy.
Acoustic neuroma surgery Damage to or cutting of the facial nerve while the tumour is removed.
Parotid gland tumours and surgery The facial nerve is at risk because it passes through the parotid gland.
Trauma / temporal bone fractures Crushing or cutting of the nerve within its canal in head injuries.
Chronic middle ear infection, cholesteatoma Spread of infection into the nerve canal.
Congenital causes (Möbius syndrome) Failure of the nerve to develop from birth.
Stroke (central palsy) The forehead and eyelid are usually spared; lagophthalmos is rarer.

Why Is an Eye That Doesn’t Close So Dangerous?

The blink reflex spreads the tear film over the cornea (the clear front layer of the eye), keeping it moist, clean and nourished. When the eye does not close, this protection is lost.

The resulting picture — exposure keratopathy:

  • Dryness, a gritty foreign-body sensation and burning
  • Redness and constant watering (a reflex response to dryness; patients describe it as “my eye is always running”)
  • Sensitivity to light
  • Blurred vision
  • Pinpoint erosions on the cornea (punctate epitheliopathy)
  • Later, a corneal ulcer
  • In the most severe cases, corneal perforation and permanent loss of vision

Three situations in particular multiply the risk:

  1. A weak Bell’s phenomenon: Normally, when the eye closes, the eyeball rolls upward and the cornea hides under the lid. If this protective reflex is weak, the cornea stays completely exposed.
  2. Reduced corneal sensation: Especially when the 5th nerve is also affected after acoustic neuroma surgery, the patient feels no pain and the damage progresses silently.
  3. Reduced tear production: Due to age, medication or involvement of the nerve branches to the lacrimal gland.

If one or more of these factors are present, the decision to operate should be made earlier.

Diagnosis: Which Assessments Are Made Before Surgery?

Correct surgical planning starts with a detailed examination:

  • Measuring lagophthalmos: The gap that remains while the patient gently closes the eye is measured in millimetres. A gap of more than 2 mm is significant.
  • Assessing Bell’s phenomenon: Whether the eyeball rolls upward is examined.
  • Slit-lamp biomicroscopy and fluorescein staining: Damage on the cornea is made visible with the dye.
  • Lower lid laxity tests: The looseness of the lid is graded with the “snap-back” and “distraction” tests.
  • Assessment of brow position and the upper lid
  • House-Brackmann scale: The degree of paralysis is graded (1–6).
  • EMG / ENoG: Provides information about the nerve’s recovery potential and helps distinguish permanent from temporary paralysis.
  • Imaging for the underlying cause: MRI or CT is essential in paralysis of unclear cause.

Before Surgery: Conservative (Non-Surgical) Treatments

Not every patient goes straight to surgery. Particularly in cases with a high chance of spontaneous recovery, such as Bell’s palsy, the aim in the first months is to protect the cornea.

Methods used:

  • Artificial tear drops: Frequently throughout the day, preferably preservative-free (single-dose) forms.
  • Gels and ointments: Especially at night, for long-lasting protection.
  • Night-time lid taping: Keeps the lid closed; skin-friendly tapes are used.
  • Moisture chamber glasses: Create a humid micro-environment around the eye.
  • Contact lens (bandage lens): Protects the cornea mechanically in selected cases.
  • Punctal plug: Prevents tears from draining away and prolongs the time they stay on the eye surface.
  • Temporary ptosis with botulinum toxin: Botox injected into the levator muscle keeps the upper lid closed for 2–3 months.

When Is Surgery Indicated?

  • If corneal damage progresses despite conservative treatment
  • If the paralysis has lasted more than 6 months with no sign of recovery
  • If the nerve has been cut surgically (no recovery is expected) — in this case intervention is made without waiting
  • If the patient cannot keep up with the drop/ointment regimen and quality of life is seriously affected
  • If corneal sensation is absent or Bell’s phenomenon is weak

Eyelid Surgery in Facial Paralysis

Surgical treatment does not consist of a single operation. The upper lid, lower lid and brow are assessed separately; in most patients two or three procedures are combined in the same session.

1. Upper Lid Loading: Gold Weight Implant

Today this is the most widely used and most effective method worldwide. Its logic is very simple: because the paralysed muscle cannot bring the lid down, a weight is added to the lid so that gravity brings it down.

How is it done?

  • It is usually performed under local anaesthesia while the patient is awake. The procedure takes about 30–45 minutes.
  • A 1.5–2 cm incision is made in the upper eyelid crease (the natural fold line) — once healed, the scar is almost invisible.
  • The muscle layer is opened and the front surface of the tarsal plate (the cartilage framework of the lid) is exposed.
  • The implant is placed in the pretarsal space, at the centre of the lid, and fixed to the tarsus with permanent sutures.
  • It is covered with muscle tissue — this step is critical to prevent the implant from becoming visible under the skin or working its way out (extrusion) later.
  • The skin is closed with fine sutures.

How is the weight chosen?

Before surgery, trial implants of different weights are taped to the outside of the lid to test how well the patient can close the eye. Typically a weight between 0.8 g and 1.6 g is chosen; the most commonly used range is 1.0–1.2 grams. The right weight is determined by testing during the examination, and the gold is then shaped by jewellers who make gold implants for this operation. The gold is then sterilised and used in the patient.

  • Implant too light → the eye still does not close fully
  • Implant too heavy → the lid droops too much (ptosis), the visual field is restricted and the lid opens slowly

Gold or platinum?

Feature Gold implant Platinum implant / chain
Density 19.3 g/cm³ 21.4 g/cm³
Volume for the same weight Larger Smaller and thinner
Visibility under the skin May be more noticeable Less noticeable
Risk of extrusion Slightly higher Lower
Allergy risk Rare; related to nickel in the alloy Very low
Fit to the lid curve Single piece, more rigid Chain model follows the lid curve
Cost More economical Higher
MRI compatibility Compatible Compatible

Today many centres abroad prefer the platinum chain implant, especially in patients with thin skin and where a more natural appearance is the goal; however, in Turkey the use of platinum is currently very limited because jewellers are not familiar with it. The gold implant nevertheless remains a reliable, widely used option with results going back many years.

Important advantage: If the nerve recovers and the eye begins to close, the implant can be removed with a short procedure. In this respect it is a reversible operation.

2. Palpebral Spring

This involves placing a spring-shaped implant made of stainless steel wire in the lid. Because it works independently of gravity, the lid closes even when the patient is lying on their back — its theoretical advantage over weight implants.

However, the spring has to be shaped individually for each patient, it can break over time due to metal fatigue, and additional procedures may be needed for adjustment. For this reason it is used more sparingly today.

3. Tarsorrhaphy (Joining the Eyelids)

Part of the upper and lower lids is stitched together to narrow the eye opening.

  • Temporary tarsorrhaphy: Provides rapid protection in intensive care patients, unconscious patients or urgent cases with a corneal ulcer.
  • Permanent lateral tarsorrhaphy: A permanent join made at the outer corner.
  • Medial (pretarsal) tarsorrhaphy: Made at the inner corner; it also supports tear drainage and is cosmetically less noticeable.

Disadvantage: It narrows the visual field and is aesthetically noticeable. It is therefore positioned as a supportive or emergency method rather than a stand-alone choice.

4. Lower Eyelid Surgery

If lower lid sagging is neglected, the eye will not close fully and the watering will continue even if an implant is placed in the upper lid.

Lateral tarsal strip: The most commonly used method. The lax tissue at the outer end of the lower lid is shortened and suspended to the inner rim of the orbital bone. The lid comes back into contact with the eyeball. It is usually performed in the same session as the upper lid implant.

Medial canthopexy / medial spindle: Corrects the outward turning of the lid at the inner corner and brings the lower tear duct opening (punctum) back into contact with the eye surface. It is effective for watering.

Spacer graft: If the lid has also shortened vertically, supporting tissue is added inside the lid. Grafts used include:

  • Ear cartilage (conchal cartilage)
  • Hard palate mucosa
  • Processed donor tissues (acellular dermal matrix)
  • Tarsoconjunctival graft (from the opposite lid)

Lower lid suspension (fascia lata or tendon sling): In severe lower lid drooping, a non-dynamic support line is created for the lid.

5. Brow Lift

In facial paralysis the forehead muscle is also paralysed, so the brow drops noticeably and rests on the upper lid, blocking the upper part of the visual field. Direct brow lift (through an incision just above the brow) is the most commonly preferred, lasting and effective method in these patients. Endoscopic brow lift is less durable in this group because the muscle is paralysed.

6. Dynamic (Reanimation) Surgery

The procedures above are “static” — they protect the eye passively. In some patients the goal is to restore active blinking:

  • Nerve transfer: Part of the nerve of one of the chewing muscles is transferred to the eyelid nerve. It should be done within one year of the onset of paralysis.
  • Cross-face nerve graft: The signal from a nerve branch on the healthy side is carried to the paralysed side with a sural nerve graft. It is usually done in two stages, and the whole process takes about a year.
  • Free muscle patch (graft): A technique that has become popular in recent years. Unlike a muscle transfer, it is done without vascular connections, which makes it an easier operation. It helps close the eye both by adding weight to the upper lid and, because it is combined with a nerve graft, through partial contraction potential. It is a suitable option for patients who do not want a gold weight.
  • Free muscle transfer (gracilis, etc.): Used primarily for the smile; in selected cases part of the muscle can also be planned for the eyelid.
  • Temporalis muscle transfer (lengthening temporalis myoplasty): Part of a chewing muscle is redirected around the lid.

These operations are more extensive, recovery takes longer, and they are usually planned for young patients with permanent paralysis and no chance of nerve recovery. They are sometimes considered alongside a gold implant as a complementary approach.

7. Botulinum Toxin (Temporary Solution)

Botox injected into the levator muscle keeps the upper lid closed for 8–12 weeks. It is used as a “bridge” before surgery, as a temporary solution for patients who do not want surgery, or for protection in paralysis that is expected to recover. It is also the main treatment for synkinesis that appears later (involuntary linked movements, such as the mouth pulling when blinking).

Which Operation for Which Patient?

Clinical situation Priority approach
Bell’s palsy, first 3 months, mild gap Conservative treatment + close follow-up
Corneal ulcer, emergency Temporary tarsorrhaphy / bandage lens, then a permanent solution
Permanent paralysis, good Bell’s phenomenon Upper lid gold implant; nerve transfer in the early period
Permanent paralysis + lower lid sagging Implant + lateral tarsal strip; nerve transfer in the early period
No corneal sensation, severe dry eye Implant + tarsal strip + medial tarsorrhaphy
Brow ptosis blocking vision Additional direct brow lift
Young patient, permanent paralysis, long-term goal Static surgery + dynamic reanimation plan
Patient not wanting surgery / recovery expected Temporary ptosis with Botox

The Surgical Process and Recovery

Preparation Before Surgery

  • Blood-thinning medications are stopped a certain time beforehand with the doctor’s approval.
  • Smoking should be stopped at least 2 weeks beforehand because it impairs wound healing.
  • Any active eye infection is treated first.
  • The implant weight is determined in advance with a trial set.

Day of Surgery

Upper lid implant and lower lid procedures are usually performed under local anaesthesia + light sedation, and the patient goes home the same day. Combined or dynamic operations may require general anaesthesia and a short hospital stay.

First Week

  • Swelling and bruising are expected; cold compresses are recommended for the first 48 hours.
  • Sleeping with the head raised reduces swelling.
  • Antibiotic eye ointment and drops are used regularly.
  • Pain is usually mild and controlled with simple painkillers.
  • Stitches are removed on days 5–7.

First Month

  • Most of the swelling subsides within 2–3 weeks.
  • Heavy exercise, bending forward, sauna and swimming are not recommended for the first 3–4 weeks.
  • Rubbing the eye must be strictly avoided.
  • Artificial tear support continues until the final position of the lid is clear.

3–6 Months

  • The incision scar fades and blends into the natural lid crease.
  • The final effect of the implant and the degree of lid closure become clear.
  • Some patients may need a small revision to adjust the weight.

Important note: In most patients, surgery reduces the need for artificial tears but may not eliminate it completely. Especially in patients with low tear production, moisturising treatment needs to continue.

Possible Risks and Complications

As with any surgical procedure, these operations carry risks. Rates are low in experienced hands, but they should be known:

  • Implant extrusion: The best-known complication; it is more common if the implant is not placed deep enough or the skin is very thin.
  • Implant migration: The implant can slip down if the sutures loosen.
  • Visibility under the skin: A bulge in the lid may be noticeable, especially in thin-skinned patients; this is less common with platinum implants.
  • Insufficient closure: If the weight is too light, an additional procedure is needed.
  • Excessive drooping (ptosis): If the weight is too heavy, the visual field is restricted.
  • Capsule formation / thickening: Scar tissue can develop around the implant.
  • Infection: Rare; usually controlled with antibiotics, and in resistant cases the implant is removed.
  • Astigmatism: Pressure of the implant on the cornea can cause a slight change in vision.
  • Allergic reaction: Rarely seen to the nickel in gold alloys or to gold itself. Removal may be necessary.
  • Asymmetry / scarring: There may be a slight difference in the lid crease.
  • After tarsorrhaphy: Narrowing of the visual field, misdirected lashes, wound breakdown.
  • After canthopexy/canthoplasty: A more almond-shaped, narrower-looking eye compared with the normal side, asymmetry.

Most of these complications are correctable. The implant can be removed, replaced or repositioned.

Success Rates and Expectations

Published series report patient satisfaction of 85–95% with upper lid weight implants. Expected benefits after surgery include:

  • A marked reduction in the lid gap (in most patients down to 0–1 mm)
  • Regression of corneal staining and signs of damage
  • A substantial reduction in how often drops/ointment are needed
  • Improvement in watering
  • Better sleep quality (less need for night-time taping)
  • Improved facial appearance as the asymmetry of the eye opening decreases

What do realistic expectations include?

These operations do not cure the paralysis or restore the nerve’s function. The goal is to protect the cornea and improve comfort. Because closure is passive, blinking is slower than normal and closure may be reduced when lying on the back. These are not failures but the natural limits of the method.

Frequently Asked Questions

If my facial paralysis recovers, will the implant stay in my eyelid?

No. If the nerve recovers and the eye starts to close on its own, the implant is usually removed with a short procedure under local anaesthesia.

How long does the operation take?

An upper lid implant alone takes 30–45 minutes; combined with a lower lid procedure it takes about 1–1.5 hours.

Is the operation painful?

Because local anaesthesia is used, no pain is felt during the procedure; there is only a slight sting during the numbing injection. Afterwards, pain is usually mild.

When can I return to work?

People with desk jobs can usually return within 3–5 days. Swelling and bruising largely resolve within 10–14 days.

Does the implant cause problems with MRI scans?

Gold and platinum are non-magnetic metals and are MRI-compatible. Even so, the radiology department should be informed about the implant before imaging.

Will I need to keep using eye drops after surgery?

In most patients the need drops considerably, but stopping completely is not recommended, especially for those with low tear production.

How long should I wait before having surgery?

In Bell’s palsy, conservative follow-up usually continues for 3–6 months. However, if the nerve has been cut surgically or corneal damage is progressing, intervention should be made without waiting.

What is done if both eyes are affected?

Bilateral paralysis (Möbius syndrome, some neurological diseases) is rare; implants can be placed in both eyes using similar principles, but with more careful weight adjustment.

Will the surgical scar be visible?

The incision is placed in the natural crease of the upper lid. Within a few months the scar fades and is practically unnoticeable when the eye is open.

Can it be done in children?

Yes, it is performed in children at risk of corneal damage; however, the weight may need to be revised as they grow.

Which doctor should I see?

In Turkey, these operations are performed by plastic and reconstructive surgeons experienced in facial paralysis. Especially if procedures such as nerve repair or muscle transfers are needed, treatment by a plastic surgeon experienced in these areas is essential. Aesthetic principles should also be taken into account in lower lid procedures. For assessment, detection and follow-up of corneal damage, review by an ophthalmologist is required, and the two specialists work together.

For a personal assessment of your situation, you can request an evaluation appointment; to learn about the surgeon’s training and experience, you can review the surgeon’s profile.

This content has been prepared for general information purposes and does not replace examination, diagnosis or treatment by a physician.

Assoc. Prof. Ahmet Hamdi Sakarya, MD, MSc

Specialist in Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery

Assoc. Prof. Ahmet Hamdi Sakarya completed a two-year fellowship in reconstructive microsurgery and peripheral nerve surgery at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital in Taiwan, one of the world’s leading high-volume microsurgery centers. His clinical practice focuses on facial paralysis and facial reanimation, brachial plexus and other peripheral nerve injuries, functional muscle transfers, free tissue transfers and facial aesthetic surgery.

Doç. Dr. Ahmet Hamdi Sakarya

Plastik, Rekonstrüktif ve Estetik Cerrahi Uzmanı. Tayvan’daki Chang Gung Memorial Hastanesinde iki yıl süreyle rekonstrüktif mikrocerrahi ve periferik sinir cerrahisi alanlarında fellowship eğitimini tamamlamıştır. Klinik pratiğinde yüz felci ve yüz reanimasyonu, brakiyal pleksus ve diğer periferik sinir yaralanmaları, fonksiyonel kas nakilleri, serbest doku aktarımları ve yüz estetik cerrahisi üzerine odaklanmaktadır.

← Geri